Hunter 2018

Research paper

Hunter JA, Hollands GJ, Couturier DL, Marteau TM. Effect of snack-food proximity on intake in general population samples with higher and lower cognitive resource. Appetite. 2018;121:337-347.

Why we cite it

A replication of the proximity effect in general-population samples rather than university students, by a team independent of Wansink, which also tests whether the effect depends on cognitive resource. The authors conclude that it is ”an effect unlikely to be moderated by cognitive resource. This indicates potential for interventions altering food proximity to contribute to addressing health inequalities, but requires testing in real-world settings.” In their Discussion, the proximity effect ”may not rely on conscious engagement to affect behaviour”. The replication is partial: Study 1 (n = 159) had a non-significant primary comparison (63.3% vs 53.8%, d = 0.22) and reached significance only after excluding the 23% of participants who moved the bowl; Study 2 (n = 246) reached significance on its primary comparison (70.7% vs 57.7%, p = 0.020). From the same Cambridge team (the Behaviour and Health Research Unit) as the Cochrane review of proximity and availability (Hollands 2019).

Known defects on this page: