Astley et al. 2018

Research paper

Astley CM, Todd JN, Salem RM, Vedantam S, Ebbeling CB, Huang PL, Ludwig DS, Hirschhorn JN, Florez JC. Genetic evidence that carbohydrate-stimulated insulin secretion leads to obesity. Clinical Chemistry. 2018;64(1):192-200. doi:10.1373/clinchem.2017.280727

Why we cite it

The study itself, in full. Two things bear on how much weight its result carries.

First, the corroboration is not independent. The review that reports this finding, Ludwig and Ebbeling 2018, is by two authors who are also authors of this study. It is not a review reporting an independent line of evidence; it is investigators citing their own work. Both are legitimate publications, and the pairing is not a defect in either, but a sentence reading “a review reports that a study found…” describes two sources where there is, in the relevant sense, one team.

Second, there is another side. A competing Mendelian randomization analysis (Richmond et al., bioRxiv 2017, a preprint) used fasting insulin and reported the reverse direction.

Known defects on this page: