Schuldt & Schwarz 2010

Research paper

Schuldt JP, Schwarz N. The “organic” path to obesity? Organic claims influence calorie judgments and exercise recommendations. Judgment and Decision Making. 2010;5(3):144-150.

Why we cite it

A demonstration of the health halo effect in two experiments, independent of Wansink’s lab. Study 1 showed that simply labeling Oreos as “organic” led participants to judge them lower in calories on a 7-point scale (b = 1.22, p < .001), even though both labels stated 160 calories. Participants also said organic cookies could be eaten more often. In Study 2 participants were "significantly more lenient toward Susie forgoing exercise when she had chosen an organic dessert" rather than a conventional one. That is a judgement about a described person, and nobody ate a dessert. Perceived goal progress is the authors' framing of the prediction ("To the extent that the act of eating organics is construed as progress toward a weight-loss goal"), not a finding. In Study 1 the effect on calorie judgments was more pronounced among participants high on pro-environmentalism; in Study 2 pro-environmentalism did not moderate the effect on leniency. The authors are independent of the Wansink research-fraud controversy: Schuldt trained under Schwarz at Michigan, not at Cornell's Food and Brand Lab.

Known defects on this page: