Automatic Eating

Most food decisions happen without conscious deliberation.

What the evidence says

  • ”It has been estimated that the majority of decisions and behaviors occur on a non-cognitive, automatic basis”, and eating ”tends to be more automatic and heuristically cued than other behaviors” — an estimate the review relays about behaviour in general, with eating singled out as more so[1]
  • The review gives no list of eating heuristics. The cues it reviews include accessibility — ”making food items more accessible increases their consumption, and reducing accessibility decreases consumption” — along with portion size, variety, salience and placement[1]
  • The review holds that ”much of human behavior is determined not by conscious intentions, but by features of the environment that operate outside of conscious awareness”, and that people ”mostly lack the capacity to consistently recognize, ignore or resist contextual cues that encourage eating”[1]
  • Cognitive load shifts food choice, in a study by Shiv and Fedorikhin that the review reports: ”participants who had to memorize a 7-digit number were 50% more likely to choose chocolate cake over fruit salad compared to participants who had to memorize a 2-digit number”. The comparison is 7-digit against 2-digit, not against no load[1]
  • The depletion explanation is reported, not established: the review writes that cognitive depletion ”is considered” a prime reason dieters fail and that dietary preoccupation ”has been considered” the primary cause, and it is from 2012, before the replication work[1]
  • The review: ”many people vehemently deny that factors other than their own internal preferences influence their decisions, even when the evidence is made explicit”; after quick decisions, people ”often manufacture a plausible reason, which is sometimes, but not always, correct”; and though ”people are aware of many contextual factors, they often do not realize how the factors influence food choices”[1]
  • In binge eating disorder, mindfulness-based eating awareness training is designed to help people reconnect with internal hunger and satiety cues and interrupt automatic eating patterns — the program’s premise, from its conceptual-foundation paper[2]