Hall et al. 2011

Research paper

Hall KD, Sacks G, Chandramohan D, Chow CC, Wang YC, Gortmaker SL, Swinburn BA. Quantification of the effect of energy imbalance on bodyweight. Lancet. 2011 Aug 27;378(9793):826-837. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(11)60812-X

Why we cite it

Provides ”a validated web-based dynamic simulation model of adult human metabolism” for predicting weight change over time, against the static “3500 kcal = 1 pound” rule, which ”ignores dynamic physiological adaptations to altered body weight”. It explains why weight loss decelerates as the body adapts, and gives a rule of thumb of 10 kcal/day per pound.

The paper distinguishes two gaps, and stresses the larger. After giving the small energy imbalance gap, it says: ”However, reversal of obesity will require substantially larger changes”.

The two gaps are different quantities and the paper names both:
– The energy imbalance gap — about 30 kJ/day — is what accumulated the weight at a population level. The paper attributes it to Hill and colleagues, not to itself, and names the ”small changes approach” it gave rise to.
– The maintenance energy gap — the increased intake needed to hold the higher weight, and therefore the size of the change needed to reverse it — is about 0.9 MJ/day (220 kcal/day) for US adults comparing 2005 with 1978. For an adult above BMI 35, representing 14% of the US population, it is greater than 2 MJ/day (500 kcal/day).

So the small number describes how the weight arrived; the large ones describe what undoing it costs — and Hall states the second explicitly: ”the large change of average energy intake characterises the magnitude of the public health challenge”.

Known defects on this page: